Thin-crust pizza · pasta · subs · salads · baskets
The Papa Gino's Menu, Category by Category
The menu is built around thin-crust pizza, with pastas, subs, salads, and baskets filling out the rest. This page walks through each category so you can decide fast, whether you are feeding one person or a full table.
Prices and availability are set by individual stores, so treat this page as a guide to what is on offer.
Check your location for the details that apply to you — your store's page shows the items and prices it actually serves.
What's on the bench tonight
- Thin-crust pizza — the signature build
- Pastas — hot and fork-friendly
- Subs — for the sandwich crowd
- Salads — the balancing order
- Baskets — shareable, hand-held sides
Jump to a category
The signature category
Thin-Crust Pizza
Pizza is the reason the chain exists, and thin crust is the style it is known for. A thin base means the toppings and cheese carry the bite rather than a heavy layer of dough, which is why it works as a shared order and as a quick solo meal.
You can keep it simple with a classic build or load it up with multiple toppings. If you are ordering for a group, two or three pies usually cover more ground than one large with everything on it, since not everyone agrees on toppings.
Building the pie
- Base — thin crust, crisp at the edge
- Cheese — carries the bite with the toppings
- Toppings — keep it classic or load it up
- For a group — two or three pies beat one with everything
Pastas
The pasta lineup gives you a hot, fork-friendly option when pizza is not the mood. It is the category that rounds out a family order, and it pairs naturally with a pizza when you want variety without ordering from two different places.
How pasta travels
Pasta travels reasonably well for takeout and delivery, though it is at its best eaten soon after it arrives. If your order is mostly pasta, plan to eat within a short window rather than letting it sit.
That makes pasta a sensible choice when you are picking up on the way home — and a less good choice if the order has to wait an hour before anyone sits down.
Pairs with
One pizza plus a pasta is the simple way to add variety without a second stop.
Subs
Subs cover the person at the table who wants a sandwich, no slice required. They are a solid choice for lunch, for a quick takeout run, and for anyone building an order that needs to stretch across different appetites.
At co-branded Papa Gino's & D'Angelo locations, the sandwich side of the menu expands to include D'Angelo grilled sandwiches and lobster rolls. That is worth knowing if your nearest store is a shared unit.
Salads
Salads do the job of balancing a heavier order. Add one to a pizza-and-pasta spread and you have something fresh on the table without a second trip.
They are also the practical pick for anyone in the group who is not in the mood for dough and cheese. It is a small category, but it earns its place in a shared order.
Baskets
Baskets are the shareable, hand-held side of the menu, and they show up in co-branded locations alongside the pizza, pasta, and sandwich lineup. They work as a starter, a side, or a casual meal on their own.
As a starter
A basket or two keeps people occupied while the pizza is on its way
As a side
Rounds out a pizza-and-pasta order without adding a main
As a meal
A basket plus a slice is a reasonable lunch for one person
Ordering From the Menu
One check decides the rest
Check whether your store is standalone or co-branded, then build the order.
That one check tells you how wide the menu actually is at your location.
Standalone stores
Pizza, pasta, subs, salads, and baskets run the full lineup here.
Co-branded stores
Adds D'Angelo grilled sandwiches and lobster rolls to that lineup.
Whichever your store is, the ordering path is the same: pick your category, add what you want, and choose delivery, takeout, or dine-in at checkout.
Feeding a Group Without Overthinking It
The reliable formula for a mixed group is one pizza per two or three people, a pasta to share, and a salad or basket to fill the gaps. Add subs if anyone is skipping the pizza entirely.
You do not need to over-plan. The categories are designed to combine, and a small order built across two or three of them tends to land better than a single large item.
Pizza
One pie per two or three people
Pasta
One pasta to share at the center
Fill the gaps
A salad or basket rounds it out
Subs slot in for anyone skipping the pizza. Build across two or three categories and the table is covered without a single oversized order.
What to Expect on First Order
If it is your first time, start with the thin-crust pizza. It is the item the chain is built on, and it tells you quickly whether the style suits you.
From there, add a pasta or a sub on your next order to explore the rest. Nothing on the menu is complicated, and that is deliberate. The goal is a straightforward order you can repeat, not a menu you have to study.
Menu questions, answered
Is the menu the same at every location?
The core lineup of pizza, pastas, subs, salads, and baskets is consistent, but co-branded Papa Gino's & D'Angelo stores add grilled sandwiches and lobster rolls. Check your store page to see which applies.
What is the signature item?
Thin-crust pizza. It is the style the chain is known for and the most direct way to judge whether Papa Gino's suits your taste.
Do you have options besides pizza?
Yes. Pastas, subs, salads, and baskets round out the menu, which is what makes it work for groups with different preferences.
Ready to build your order?
Start with the thin-crust pizza, or check your local store first if you want to know whether grilled sandwiches and lobster rolls are on the menu where you are. Either way, ordering takes a few minutes.